Catholic Exchange

Loving our Fellow Mothers: How to End the Mommy Wars

The greatest commandment tells us to “Love God and Love Your Neighbor as Yourself.” Sometimes it seems that the hardest “neighbors” for us mothers to love are our fellow mothers. The “mommy wars” are so much a part of life. If a group of mothers gets together and any parenting subject comes up, chances are there will be a debate on the “correct” way to parent. The battles start even when a child is still in the womb. There are the big topics of course such as working vs. staying-at-home or breast-feeding vs. bottle feeding. There are many other smaller hot-button topics as well: natural vs. medicated childbirth, public vs. private vs. home education, whether to celebrate Halloween or not, the proper way to feed one’s family, co-sleeping vs. having a child sleep alone, comforting a child at night when he is crying vs. letting him cry it out, how to discipline, the correct way to bring up a child in the faith, and the list goes on.

We mothers don’t necessarily intend to be mean or critical of other mothers. Rather, we simply want to do the best for our children. Parenting can be so hard and we don’t know how things will turn out for at least twenty years. There is always the element of uncertainty. We each make the decisions that we feel are right. We get so invested in the choices and sacrifices we make. It is easy to think that if we have made the right choices, then different choices must therefore be wrong. We also sometimes feel so certain of our choices that we try to convince others that they should follow the same path.

So, then, what is a mother to do? How can we be comfortable with our own choices, while respecting the choices of others? The answer does lie in that great commandment to love one another. There is an old adage not to judge another person until one has walked a mile in her shoes. While mothers have many things in common, the journey each mother takes is unique. We each come to parenting with different backgrounds and experiences. We each have different levels of support from our spouses (or lack thereof), our extended families, and friends. We have different health issues and personal abilities. We have different economic realities that we need to deal with. Perhaps most importantly, we have different children. Parents with more than one child know that what works for one child doesn’t always work for a different child, even when those children come from the same gene pool. The “right” decision for one child isn’t always the “right” decision for another child. Different stages of life also can require different choices.

Perhaps the next time we are tempted to judge another mother or the decisions she has made, we can step back and take a moment to reflect. We can remember that we don’t want our parenting to be judged and that we should give others the same courtesy. We can also remember that motherhood is hard and we don’t know what challenges the mothers we encounter are facing. We can recall that Jesus told us to love one another. We need to respect and support our fellow mothers on this difficult journey. We need to stand by each other and encourage each other, not tear each other down. Hopefully, then, the “mommy wars” could come to an end.

Comments

7 responses to “Loving our Fellow Mothers: How to End the Mommy Wars”

  1. Claire Avatar
    Claire

    Thank you for this article, Patrice. On a Catholic mothering internet group I belong to, I often feel like an outsider because I don’t co-sleep, breastfeed my adopted son, or plan to homeschool, and therefore am not subscribing to the “Attachment Parenting” lifestyle which seems to have become the official Catholic parenting approach. I feel that my son and I are very attached, and if I had given birth to him and didn’t have to work fulltime (my husband and I juggle our schedules so he is not in daycare), I would have liked to have exclusively breastfed him. Co-sleeping, on the other hand, is not something I’m comfortable with. I often feel judged for this. Mothers really do need to be more tolerant of each other.

  2. elkabrikir Avatar
    elkabrikir

    Good points, Patrice.

    Claire,

    I would have contacted you personally, however, I, like Patrice, think this issue affects many women. Perhaps they could also benefit from my post.

    As you know I’ve been doing this mothering “gig” also called a vocation, for over 20 years. I’m raising my 11 children according to the gifts God has given me with rectitude of intention.

    My most important advice is put God first in your family. Then what you specifically are called to do within your vocation as wife and mother will crystalize. I believe pride drives many of these conversations about Parenting Perfection. Make your decision based on what is best for your family at any specific moment in time. Don’t be dogmatic but rather flexible within the framework of the teachings of the Church. Once your decision is made, don’t look left or right. You don’t need the approval from anybody else regarding your choices. Think of Jesus who stayed in Galilee and only arrived for the feast at the last moment. His disciples must have wondered. But, Jesus knew what he was doing and didn’t give any explanations or excuses.

    “Jesus and Jerusalem
    (7:1-13)

    1 After this Jesus was traveling around in Galilee. He did not want to go around in Judea because the Jewish authorities wanted to kill him. 2 Now the Jewish feast of Tabernacles was near. 3 So Jesus’ brothers advised [said to] him, “Leave here and go to Judea so your disciples may see your miracles that you are performing. 4 For no one who seeks to make a reputation for himself does anything in secret. If you are doing these things, show yourself to the world.” 5 (For not even his own brothers believed in him.) 6 So Jesus replied, “My time has not yet arrived, but you are ready at any opportunity. 7 The world cannot hate you, but it hates me, because I am testifying about it that its deeds are evil. 8 You go up to the feast yourselves. I am not going up to this feast yet,56 because my time has not yet fully arrived.” 9 When he had said this, he remained in Galilee. 10 But when his brothers had gone up to the feast, then Jesus himself also went up, not openly but in secret. ”

    I could give you numerous examples of moms who boast about how little they spend and their creativity in saving money by driving to garage sales all Sat morning, how cloth diapers really do save the planet, how co-sleeping is the only way for a family to bond, how breastfed babies are never sick and much smarter, how homeschooling meets the needs of every child if you just try hard enough, ad nauseum.

    I’ve watched moms be kicked off their high horse by life experience. What’s sad is that many of these moms were living somebody else’s expectation in the first place and felt guilty about their imperfect imitation of another’s original.

    You have unique gifts and so do each of the members of your family. Therefore, your family life will be perfectly you. Drop out of groups where you perceive pressure to conform until you are strong enough within yourself to handle their imagined, subtle or overt comments. And remember, the other moms are “works in progress” too.

    Jeffrey is not the only person blossoming in your family. A mother and father are tender buds too and need to be nurtured with patient, gentle love. I support you. Most importantly, Jesus has shown the way through these situations. Cling to him and persevere in faith and you will be conformed to Christ. Divine Wisdom, a gift of the Holy Spirit, will help you see the truth in all things.

  3. on a journey Avatar
    on a journey

    Great article Patrice—and also great post Elka. My own experience has shown that I start to compare myself when I am unsure of myself. And then, when I find something that works, I tend to think it will work forever and with every child…..how wrong I have been time and time again. I hope I’m not a mom who shoves my practices down the throats of other moms. I do try every day to be a child-specific mom and rely on the gifts God has given me and the grace He has to shower me with each and every day.

    Hang in there Claire! God gave your child to YOU and YOUR HUSBAND–not someone else. He has a plan for you and trusts that you can attain His goals for that child of His!

  4. Lucky Mom of 7 Avatar
    Lucky Mom of 7

    I’ve pointed out on more than one occasion that St. Gianna Molla put her kids in daycare when they were very little. She was a physician. It can’t be inherently evil if St. Gianna was canonized. 😉

    I think the “mommy wars” contribute to contraception use and abortion. Women get so overwhelmed with the quest to be perfect mothers, that they lose sight of the inherent dignity in each child. The evil one loves the in-fighting, I’m sure.

    Hugs to all the moms who read this. Your vocation is holy and God has a unique plan for you that doesn’t hinge on anybody else’s opinions.

    Lucky

  5. Loretta Avatar
    Loretta

    Speaking of motherhood… On A Journey…
    You littlest one must be breathing oxygen in the open atmosphere now, right?
    When was he/she born?!?
    (and a belated congrats!)

  6. Claire Avatar
    Claire

    A lot of great posts. Thanks for the support, everyone. Lucky, you are so right that the devil loves it when mothers fight among themselves.

  7. vtanco Avatar
    vtanco

    One’s parenting journey can take many twists and turns. Often in the search for the best mommy award, a person tries one perceived best ideology after another, each time thinking it is the optimum thing, then finding it wasn’t so great after all, or that it didn’t work with the next child. Sometimes it is just a matter of maturing (otherwise known as getting older and wiser) to get to the point of being comfortable and happy with your life and parenting choices. Not coincidentally, this stage often parallels one’s growth in faith and dependence on God.

Leave a Reply