Catholic Exchange

USCCB’s Review of Hairspray

Hairspray (New Line) is an uplifting, enjoyable adaptation of the hit Broadway musical based, in turn, on John Waters' 1988 film of the same title about an overweight 1962 Baltimore teenager named Tracy Turnblad (Nikki Blonsky).

Her parents, Wilbur (Christopher Walken), who owns a novelty shop, and Edna (John Travolta in a cross-dressing role), who takes in laundry, support her dreams of competing on "The Corny Collins Show," a racially segregated local dance program. The so-called "Negro Day," hosted by affable blonde-wigged Motormouth Maybelle (Queen Latifah), only airs monthly.

WYZT producer Velma Von Tussle (Michelle Pfeiffer) aims to keep the status quo, and since she's looking to further the interests of her spoiled daughter, Amber (Brittany Snow), in the "Miss Teenage Hairspray" dance competition, does her best to undermine Tracy's efforts — even, at one point, trying to seduce the clueless Wilbur.

But eternal optimist Tracy — who cares not a jot for what people think of her bodily heft — perseveres, and catching the eye of Collins (James Marsden), appears on the show and proves a hit. She also wins the admiration of school hunk Link Larkin (Zac Efron), and talks her reclusive mother into finally leaving the house, and getting a makeover at the dress shop of Mr. Pinky (Jerry Stiller, the earlier film's Wilbur).

With the help of Maybelle and the African-American kids at her high school, including Maybelle's son, Seaweed (Elijah Kelley), whose kid sister, Little Inez (Taylor Parks), turns out to be a dance whiz herself, Tracy determines to integrate the show. Her best friend, Penny Pingleton (Amanda Bynes), falls for Seaweed, underscoring that theme. (Penny's disapproving and fanatical mom, Prudy — Allison Janney of "The West Wing," is the source of a mildly irreverent sight gag.)

Maybelle's stirring civil rights number — "I Know Where I've Been" — is sung during a nighttime protest march to the TV station and provides the film's most serious, genuinely moving sequence.

With a screenplay by Leslie Dixon (adapted from the stage script by Mark O'Donnell and Thomas Meehan), director Adam Shankman keeps the pace moving and maintains a sensible balance between heightened realism and more fanciful elements.

There are impressive performances from a well-chosen cast, led by lovable newcomer Blonsky. As with the stage interpreters of the role, Travolta admirably plays it straight, though the fat suit needn't have been so exaggerated. His and Walken's old-fashioned vaudeville number is a highlight, but Mark Shaiman and Scott Wittman's songs are all exceedingly well performed.

The film is rife with themes of racial tolerance, anti-discrimination and self-respect. And there are positive pro-family messages in the supportive relationships in the Turnblad and Maybelle households.

Above all, underdog Tracy's fierce determination to do "what's right" makes the film as meritorious as it is entertaining.

The film contains some crass expressions, innuendo, mild sexual banter and irreverence, and brief teen smoking, making this best for older adolescents. The USCCB Office for Film & Broadcasting classification is A-II — adults and adolescents. The Motion Picture Association of America rating is PG — parental guidance suggested. Some material may not be suitable for children.

Comments

  1. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    how could this bishops say this movie is acceptable for adults and adolescents..  this movie is full of of trashy stuff and immodesty..

    no catholic in good conscience can see this movie..

    would you watch this movie if Jesus Christ was sitting next to you?

    don't lie … you know you wouldn't.    

    look it up on the website  http://www.kidsinmind.com   and you will see all of the trash in the movie…   let's stop offending Christ by seeing movies like this..  and let us stop saying that it is okay to see it because their are some good things in it.. 

    we can not to say to Jesus on judgement day.. "well i only saw the movie because i heard it had a good message.. that's why i allowed myself to see the other filth that was in it." 

    that's not going to be acceptable before God.

  2. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    I thought "papal bull" might be overreacting, but after checking out the recommended kidsinmind.com site, I have to agree with papal bull when he/she says, "let us stop saying that it is okay to see it because there are some good things in it."  Hairspray is filled with wincing rudeness and sexual innuendo.  Kidsinmind is not just for kids – it is an excellent site offering specific details within each movie under the headings: Sex/Nudity, Profanity and Violence.  Thanks for the heads-up.  The USCCB missed the boat on this one. 

  3. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    God loves you .

    Yes – it does look like the bishops should have used the movie review (and all movie reviews they publish) to contrast the various sins and attitudes in the movie to the Commandments, the Beatitudes, better habits and attitudes, etc. Any confusion about Christian doctrine caused by the movie content could be clarified.

    But, I have to admit that the USCCB misses many opportunities to exemplify and exhort Catholicism on many issues that our modern worldliness portends and permits Satan to proselytize. Our shepherds seem to give too much of themselves to relative mediocrity.

    Remember, I love you, too

    Reminding that we are all on the same side – His,

    Pristinus Sapienter

    (wljewell @catholicexchange.com or … yahoo.com)

  4. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    Heh, that is exactly what EegahInc does over at his B-Movie Catechism blog. It’s good fun, though none of the movies are likely to be things your children are clamoring to see.

  5. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    My question is this:  Do the bishops themselves personally review all these movies or do the liberal elitists who work in the offices of the USCCB actually give the "thumbs up" to garbage like Hairspray?  If you remember back when The Passion of the Christ came out, the "spokespersons" at the USCCB trashed it as anti-semitic!  Have they ever actually read the Gospels?  Me thinks its past time to "clean house" at the USCCB!

  6. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    I have long ago given up on listening to what the bishops say regarding films.  I use online sites to determine for myself.  The one I use most (just the facts!)  is screenit.com

  7. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    I went and saw the film because a friend wanted to go and after reading the reviews and seeing it was PG I thought it would be OK.  I would have given this movie a PG-13 rating for the dancing alone.  To put this in the same category as some REAL children's films is outrageous.  What shocks me about this review, however, is that there is no mention of the blatant anti-Catholic stereo-typing they did in one of the characters, Prudy, Penny's mom.

    At one point, this character throws a rosary at her daughter telling her to pray for Tracy.  Then, after helping Tracy, the mother ties her daughter to a bed with a jump-rope and sprinkles what can only be holy water on her and calls her "Devil child, devil child!"  (It could be "Demon child," I can't remember.)

    I can't tell you how shocked I was.  Here was a movie about tearing down bigotry and prejudice surrounding race and the dignity of people of all sizes, but religious prejudice is still acceptable.  Don't the film makers realize what hypocrites it makes them?  The fact that this review doesn't even mention it is even more shocking.  As a Catholic, I feel personally attacked whenever this happens in a film or television, I can't help it.  If you're at all sensitive to this type of thing, don't go see the movie.  Don't get me started on the suggestive dancing, its not as bad as other movies, but with a PG movie, I expected better.

  8. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    The blatant anti-Catholic scene with Prudy(oh, how lame) is typical of Hollywood's mockery of our Faith.

    If the USCCB ignores the ridicule, as well as the average movie goer, Catholic included, what can you expect but continued and ever increasing mockery?

    They get away with it because we let them.

Leave a Reply