Catholic Exchange

St. Ignatius of Loyola: Madman or Militant Monk?

In times of insanity, only the relatively insane have the courage to be sane. In this paradox lies the paradox of salvation itself: that the seemingly mad are the ones to save the world from madness. St. Ignatius of Loyola was a knight errant for Our Lady who charged the giant windmills of his lifetime with the unconquerable valor of Don Quixote, proving himself, though often battered and bruised, a mighty champion who led an army on for the greater glory of God.

In a tumultuous century for the Catholic Church, where Pope Leo X fussed as Luther became popular, and Hadrian VI fussed against the Turks, and Clement VII fussed with the Habsburgs, and Paul III fussed over commissions from Michelangelo, a knight was born to the Church in the Castle of Loyola in Guipuscoa, Spain, 1491. Ignatius was reared from his boyhood in the arts of chivalry in the court of Ferdinand V of Aragon.

Known for his eyes that pierced like swords, Ignatius was driven by youthful daydreams of military prowess. After his riotous and amorous service at court, he was stationed at the barracks of Pamplona in 1517. Having established himself there as a wild and winsome soldier, he heroically led his comrades in the defense of the city against France’s siege, falling only after a cannonball shattered his right leg. With the loss of Ignatius, the city soon surrendered, and his French conquerors demonstrated their admiration for their gallant foe by bearing him with courtesy and care back to the Castle of Loyola to recover.

Ignatius’ convalescence was a prolonged and painful one—his broken leg required re-breaking and resetting on two occasions. The boisterous knight lay abed, restless and racked; and though his reading had up to that time been entirely devoted to the romantic escapades of Amadis of Gaul, El Cid, and those tomes of chivalry which broke the brain of the Knight of La Mancha, all he had at that time were two unfamiliar histories: the life of Jesus Christ and the lives of His saints. Reluctance and tedium flung obstacles in his mind, but his high-stepping imagination soon found its pace in the escapades of the heroes of the Church. Ignatius saw unfolding before him a marvelous myriad of chivalric battles and enraptured ends that put all his beloved legends to shame—or rather, gave them a purpose within a drama he had never dreamed. The Crusades were rekindled in the wounded Knight of Loyola as he vowed to rival the saints in sanctity. He swore to take Jerusalem from the hands of the heathen. His piercing eyes narrowed. He laid his naked sword over his knees and waited his day of healing.

But the fires of Ignatius’ spirit were, even then, to be redirected. As he lay upon his couch, a Lady appeared to him more resplendent than any lady of any knight errant before. Ignatius took up her favor with awe, and all concupiscence fled his body leaving him with a new vision of martial conquest. The knight would win over the world in the name of the Lady he served—the Virgin Mother of God—not through sheer militarism, but militant mysticism. As soon as he could walk, Ignatius went to the Benedictine monastery of Santa Maria de Montserrat, laid his armor before an image of Mary, and then went on foot to a remote cave in the solitudes of Manresa where he spent ten months in rigid self-mortification. There in that cave, Ignatius prepared his heart for a new type of battle, training in the arms of the spirit, and strengthening his resolve to serve heaven through prayer and fasting. There in that cave, Ignatius learned the secret arts of asceticism and discovered the foundation of what would become his famous meditations, Spiritual Exercises. He emerged from the darkness of that cave and out of the dark night of his soul lean and battered, but happy—ready to march for the Holy Land.

The next two years, however, were plagued with setbacks, sickness, and severities. The Franciscans thought Ignatius a madman and refused to support his mission to take back Jerusalem. Ignatius eventually found himself in Barcelona in 1524, where he decided that, given his struggles, study was his best option. He undertook the rigors of forming his mind as rigorously as he had formed his body to be a soldier, and he who had fought and felled in fiery battles and duels, sat alongside youngsters bent over Latin books despite the mockery of men. He soon took up studies at the University of Paris, but was ever beset with difficulties arising from his street-corner, missionary zeal, such as ruffians beating him for trying to protect prostitutes and even imprisonment twice by the Inquisition on suspicion of his being a member of a heretical group.

For all of these trials, however, it was in Paris that a small group of followers gathered around the strange and striking ascetic, and he led them in doing works for the poor, in studies, and community prayer like a military officer. It was with these companions that Ignatius renewed his determination to preach in the Holy Land. Together, these seven men vowed lifelong labor as missionaries. The Society of Jesus was born. These Crusaders, the first Jesuits, then marched over the Alps toward Jerusalem, but, to their dismay, found Venice ravaged by war with the Turks. Their passage was blocked and Ignatius’ mission was foiled yet again.

They received permission to be ordained to the priesthood while in Venice, after which, they turned their footsteps toward Rome to place themselves at the disposal of the Pope. Presenting themselves to Paul III, some were charged with teaching positions, others with hospital duties, yet others with founding schools, while Ignatius drafted and expanded the official rule for his newly founded community, a task he continued for the duration of his life. The rule consisted of the usual vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience, but, in keeping with the military flare of Ignatius, obedience to the superior and to the pope was emphasized over the other two. Also, members were given training parallel to military training, complete with orders, drills, and a hierarchy or ranks, for Ignatius thought of his brethren as soldiers who would need the strength of discipline and the subtleties of wisdom to wage and win wars on spiritual battlefields. The Pope approved the order in 1540 and Ignatius was elected the first General Superior.

The Jesuits rapidly rose to become a power to reckon with in the Catholic Church. Their spirituality was one of unwavering faith, indomitability, and intellectual acumen. They clashed with Protestants, rescued beleaguered Catholics in England, defended the borders of France from heresy, and won over the loyalty of thousands to God and His Church. No challenge was too daunting, difficult, or dangerous, for each member of the Society wished to prove himself in daunting, difficult, and dangerous work. They marched to India, China, and Japan. They sailed to the New World. They conquered countless souls for Christ.

St. Ignatius of Loyola trained bodies and minds to better serve in the army of the Lord. His military-grade mysticism prepared, protected, and preserved the Jesuits against any foe, no matter how terrible, making St. Ignatius one of those quixotic and chivalric lunatics who refuse with an idiot determination to surrender to the ravings of a world gone mad, and thereby serve in the knighthood of heaven.

Comments

14 responses to “St. Ignatius of Loyola: Madman or Militant Monk?”

  1. Michael Dowd Avatar
    Michael Dowd

    I wonder what St. Ignatius would say about his order if he came back today? About their drift into secularism and significant abandonment of the sacred. About a Jesuit Pope, with his confusing statements about Catholic doctrine, is leading many astray. About their support of left wing political causes versus their lack of interest in eternal life.

  2. Robyn Dolan Avatar

    What a delightful and inspiring look at the life of Ignatius.

  3. noelfitz Avatar
    noelfitz

    This is a powerful and insightful article, showing the strength and weakness of Jesuit/Ignatian spirituality. Prior to Ignatius the Church’s moral teaching, following St Thomas Aquinas, focused on virtue and good habits, but with Ignatius came a change to emphasizing obedience. At present there is a movement back to virtue ethics.

    This emphasis was on obedience to orders given by superiors, not personal
    conscience, and the article clearly illustrates the influence of Ignatius’ military background.

    This emphasis, if carried to extremes, leads to problems, illustrated in our own time, most notably, by the abuses in the Legionaries of Christ. Also many abuses in the Catholic Church might unfortunately be due to blindly following orders, rather than conscience.

  4. Dr.Cajetan Coelho Avatar
    Dr.Cajetan Coelho

    Lord, teach me to be generous.
    Teach me to serve you as you deserve;
    to give and not to count the cost,
    to fight and not to heed the wounds,
    to toil and not to seek for rest,
    to labor and not to ask for reward,
    save that of knowing that I do your will.

  5. Sam Avatar
    Sam

    Quite a rousing tale. Thank you.

  6. Sam Avatar
    Sam

    It would be interesting to hear what he would have to say. Would he indeed view it as you seem to think he would, or would he view it the opposite in fact. Unfortunately, we will never know…

  7. kirk Avatar
    kirk

    Noelfitz: In your last paragraph, you mention “abuses” in the CC from blindly following orders. Do you have particular abuses in mind, or general ones? I do recognize some, but perhaps not many.

  8. kirk Avatar
    kirk

    I am a Catholic because of a superb Jesuit priest; I’ve been a SEEL (Spiritual Exercise in Everyday Life) participant and director; I’ve known many very spiritual Jesuit priests and SEEL directors – and it is from that vantage point that I view the Jesuit Order and lay people. I know that in any Order, there are the very spiritual and the least spiritual in their personal lives, just like those who are not in an Order, but their level of spirituality is not mine to judge. From what vantage point do you base your comments? Is it because you know one or ten bad apples, or because you are overly rigid in your interpretation of Catholic theology? That was the reason Jesus could not win over the Pharisees, they were so rigid in their laws that they could not recognize the good. Don’t get me wrong, i’m not saying that Catholic teaching can be “downsized” – but that does not mean we close our minds to the inspiration of the Holy Spirit and render anathema any “strange” words or action said or done by Pope Francis or any other Jesuit.

  9. Michael Dowd Avatar
    Michael Dowd

    Thanks Kirk. My personal experiences with the Jesuits have been excellent over many years. I went to a Jesuit College and went to their daily Mass at their Manresa Retreat House in Michigan. More specifically from a critical point of view I was referring to the South American Jesuits, like our Pope, who are infected with Liberation Theology, which is basically Communistic, and concerned mostly with the things of this world.

    Just think about how many times have you heard Pope Francis speaking about eternal life and how we are to get there? We know how concerned is about “climate change” and economics, things he knows nothing about. We know how concerned he about the materially poor but how concerned is he about the poor in spirit which was the only kind of poor that Christ admired.

    Anyway. God Bless you and all you do.

  10. kirk Avatar
    kirk

    Thanks for the explanation – I will listen with more critical thought to the popes messages, though I love the way he has resonated with Catholics who had fallen away from the practice of it; many have returned, and that is good.
    Here’s a quote from Richard John Neuhaus “…the teaching of the Church is lived forward, not reconstructed backward.” I believe that to be absolutely true, and needs to be protected. We also need dialog with kindness, or we turn people away from the faith. This has happened too many times in our history. I pray that we can all see the difference between truth and error.

  11. noelfitz Avatar
    noelfitz

    Kirk,

    Many thanks for your reply to my post. I had hoped it would get a response, and was disappointed when initially it seemed to have been ignored.

    Do you agree with my main point, that prior to Ignatius’ time the emphasis in Catholic ethics was on virtue and developing good habits, but Ignatian spirituality emphasized military style obedience to commands? Bur recently there is a movement back to virtue ethics.

    You ask what abuses I had in mind. I had in mind partially the sexual abuse of children, but my main concern was the abuses in the Legionaries of Christ under Fr Marcial Maciel. As well as vows of poverty, chastity and obedience they took an additional vow never to criticize superiors, but this private vow was abolished in 2006. This vow may have allowed Fr Maciel to continue his abuses for years.

    However I hope my post was not considered an attack on the Church, but a comparison of ethics pre- and post- Ignatius.

  12. noelfitz Avatar
    noelfitz

    The responses to this article are interesting, showing different views among faithful Catholics. It is no bad thing that we disagree on some issues. Respectfully I disagree with Michael Dowd, as his main point seems to be that he disagrees with the pope.

  13. kirk Avatar
    kirk

    Noelfitz: I know what you mean by being disappointed with no responses. Sometimes I think long on a subject and think my post is good, but there is no response. I’m sure the columnists feel that way at times too.
    I think in the beginning of a new order, as in Ignatian spirituality, new problems have new solutions. It began with developing virtues, and as time passed other disciplines were added, obedience adopted only when needed. Maybe there was a bit of contention between himself and his followers. As in any group dynamics, whenever two people speak their minds, there are fifty arguments (at least).
    I haven’t read enough about the Legionaries of Christ or Fr. Marcial Maciel so could not make a comment. I’ve heard of them of course, but that’s all. Maybe after I finish my current projects…(so much to read, so little time!)

  14. noelfitz Avatar
    noelfitz

    Kirk,

    Many thanks for your friendly reply to me. It is much appreciated.

    I have a ‘thing’ about the Jesuits. I found the Spiritual Exercises of Ignatius dishonest. In the old days, when I did them, it seemed that what was done first was to destroy one’s self-confidence and sense of worth, then to rebuild it in differently. I have mentioned this to others and they point out that the Ignatian Exercises I experienced were not the true Exercises, or alternatively the Exercises have now changed.

    In Ireland the Jesuits were up near the top of the wealthy, powerful, educated Catholic class, being second only to Benedictines. But recently their ‘option to the poor’ seems to have back-fired. New recruits have almost disappeared and in Ireland and Britain they seem to be retiring from educational and spiritual initiatives.

Leave a Reply