Catholic Exchange

Appeals Court Rejects Special Rights for Transsexuals

A federal appeals court has issued a significant ruling saying that an employer's concern over the use of restrooms by "transsexual" employees is legitimate, according to Alliance Defense Fund Senior Legal Counsel Brian Raum. He explained further that the court ruled that "transsexuals" do not qualify as a protected class under Title VII.

"The court delivered a significant legal punch to political special interest groups who are demanding that persons with Gender Identity Disorder be treated as though they were members of the opposite sex. The court correctly ruled that employers have a valid concern regarding their employees' proper use of public restrooms," said Raum.

The US Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit ruled that the Utah Transit Authority had a legitimate concern over a male employee's restroom usage. Michael Etsitty, a male employee, had begun taking female hormone therapy and wearing women's jewelry and makeup but still had male sex organs. UTA had liability concerns regarding the man's use of women's bathrooms.

Read the ruling in Etsitty v. Utah Transit Authority.

Comments

  1. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    Gender Identity Disorder, acronym GID, as in gid out of here?

  2. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    Thanks for my last laff of the night!

     

  3. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    I've heard about this.  In some companies, employees can get disciplined for sexual harrassment if they complain about a transsexual using the wrong bathroom.  Whose rights are being denied here?

  4. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    This isn't just theoretical — I was actually faced with this in the work place! Over two decades ago, one of my "fellow" employees was a transsexual. I thought our employer handled the situation exactly right, asking the employee to use a "single door" bathroom.

    Sadly, after living the required year dressing as a woman, the employee had "the" operation, and then began to use the regular ladies room. I never had the courage to complain, but it did bother me.

Leave a Reply