Catholic Exchange

Words of Wisdom… about a Painful Subject

When I was eighteen, I found out I was pregnant. My boyfriend said he'd kick me out of our apartment if I didn't have an abortion, and my employer agreed that this was the only logical option. She even offered to make the arrangements.

My experience at the abortion clinic was painful and humiliating. I cried that day . . . and the next. Then I cried alone because my boyfriend and I broke up.

Although I hadn't felt this way before, it was clear to me afterwards that abortion had ended the life of my child. I felt guilty and had a sense that I deserved to be punished — in fact, I desired punishment. As a result, I sank into depression and self-destructive behavior.

My experience brought me to church, but I wasn't sure that Jesus could forgive me. I often found myself thinking that if people in the nearby pews knew what I had done, they wouldn't shake my hand — and certainly wouldn't sit next to me.

The worse I felt, the more I tried to do penance by volunteering at a pregnancy center. Eventually, the director found out about my abortion and encouraged me to attend a healing workshop. This helped me not only to grieve the loss of my child, but also to identify my unhealthy behaviors. It took me several more years to finish my journey to wholeness, but things progressively improved as I learned to act on the truth of God's mercy and redemptive grace.

One in Three

Today, I spend much of my time helping other people whose lives have been touched by abortion. I also work with young people to help them develop critical thinking skills, value life, and make choices they will not regret. I have found that how we live our lives and how we treat people are much more important than what we say. Of course, it's important to be informed and clear about the issues (the United States Catholic Bishops' Conference is a good resource: www.usccb.org). But if we want our conversations to be productive rather than polarizing, we need to give some thought to how we communicate. Abortion isn't just an abstraction or a subject for idle philosophizing. For all too many people, it is intensely personal — a raw and painful topic. At current abortion rates, it is estimated that one in three women in the United States will have had an abortion by age forty-five. But it isn't just these women who are affected: The list includes spouses, partners, children, other family members, and friends. In fact, it is becoming rare not to know someone who has had an abortion. This is one reason why it is so difficult to engage in a reasoned discussion of the subject. Often, even without our knowing it, people may be interpreting our words and actions through a screen of painful personal experiences. If we want to change hearts and minds and model the love and mercy of Christ, then their experiences must be considered.

 Do They Need to Grieve?

When the topic of abortion comes up, bear in mind that the person you are speaking to may have been impacted by abortion. If so, the first need is for healing. This is why it helps to understand something about reproductive grief. It's normal to grieve after any pregnancy loss, whether it is caused by miscarriage, stillbirth, adoption, infertility, or abortion. Most of us know someone who has suffered the loss of a child through miscarriage. The loss suffered in an abortion is similar, except for two important distinguishing factors: First, the loss is chosen, often after succumbing to pressure from others; second, the abortion is typically kept a secret. Talking is an important part of grieving a loss like this. But people who are carrying the burden of a past abortion — either their own or someone else's — often feel that they're the only ones having a difficult reaction. Their sense of isolation keeps them from reaching out to others. Sometimes they encounter pro-life people who condemn them, and pro-choice people who deny their feelings. Finding no safe place to deal with their troubling emotions, they may choose to repress or numb them in order to cope. And even when they want to talk about their experiences, well-meaning family and friends often urge them to simply move on with their lives and "forget about it." Thus, abortion can cause emotional scars with lifelong effects. So be alert to this need for healing. And if you discover that you are indeed speaking with someone who has been impacted by abortion, offer to connect them with healing resources and to support them through the process.

And As You Speak . . .

Pray. Immerse every encounter and conversation in prayer. Ask the Holy Spirit to guide you, to open hearts, and to communicate His truth, love, and grace through you.

Respect

Exemplify Jesus' love by showing genuine care and concern for the people you talk to, regardless of their stand on abortion. Keep in mind that most people who support abortion are concerned about women who live in difficult situations and about babies whom they fear will be neglected. They, too, feel uncomfortable with the high rate of abortions and wish there were better solutions for women experiencing unexpected pregnancies.

Believe it or not, we share a lot of common ground with many of those who label themselves "pro-choice." An attitude of respect enables us to work on practical solutions together. And by seeking to build a genuine connection, we affirm their intrinsic value and worth. Listen. Give people some space. Patiently listen to their opinions and concerns. We can learn a lot when we stay silent, quiet our minds, and truly listen. Also, some people need time to process their thoughts and feelings. By listening to them attentively, we make it easier for them to work things through and to arrive at greater clarity. In all these ways, we help build a culture of life. By communicating sensitively and compassionately, we can be a source of healing and understanding. We can bring the love of Jesus to the world.

Comments

  1. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    I am glad you have written this, and that you are healing and helping others.  But once again the headline is misleading.  This is not a 'painful subject.'  Stubbing a toe is a painful subject.  Abortion is devasting, it is murder, it is a collusion and collaboration of evil forces, upon the innocent – often the mother, always the child.  It has destroyed our society in so many ways, hurt so many people, been ignored by the media, cooperated in evil, ravaged the economy and schools, and allowed men and boys to prey on women and girls.

    It is difficult to 'engage,' because so many of the 'facts' that 'the other side' has are lies or misrepresentations. In three + decades, the media has distorted what REALLy is a simple thing to a mess.  IT IS A SIN TO KILL AN INNOCENT child.  The media and planned parenthood and NARAL etc have made it so much more than that with all the weirdness they all possess. They would like people to think is a sin to allow the child to live!  or heaven forbid, be adopted!!!

    It's not 'pro-choice,' it's pro-abortion or pro-murder.  And many pro-lifers of course share things with pro-aborts, but there is a deliberate ignorance in this day and age for pro-aborts.  They don't want to give up their connection to selfishness.  Whatever was thought by 9 men on a bench in the '70's melts away in the face of a 2008 4-d sonogram

    God help us

  2. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    deirdrew, you did not offer your suggestion for a headline. 

  3. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    I am also glad you wrote this, because I have inadvertently stuck my foot in my mouth a large number of times by using deirdrew's arguments (no matter how valid) on a person whom I had no idea was dealing with the awful feelings of having had an abortion.  The "taste of toe jam" finally taught me to be more gentle in engaging with others on this topic, because all too often, no matter which side they took, the person I was speaking to was profoundly impacted by abortion – and heaping pain on top of pain serves absolutely NO useful purpose.

  4. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    MIchaelene,

    From my experience you are 100% correct in your approach. I have had numerous encounters with women who eventually confess they have had an abortion.

    Sometimes the admission comes after years of friendship (a relative by marriage) and sometimes during a chance encounter of 30 minutes (a realtor showing me a model home).  Once a 19 year old told me of her abortion 5 years earlier, and ensuing alcoholism, while we were babysitting young dancers during The Nutcracker. 

    All those women knew my strong pro life stance.  However, they didn't feel threatened or attacked because I tried to implement the strategies with love that you enumerated.  I will never know if any woman has been hurt by my comments to her.  But, I can only pray that as in all our encounters,  a post abortive woman  feels she has encountered Christ.  

    Using St Josemaria Escriva's words "Christ is passing by" regardless of which party you are.

  5. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    Dear Michaelene: I'm so sorry for your loss. You're right, we tend to be more sympathetic toward someone who has had a miscarriage than someone who chose abortion. (Although in many cases "choose" is too strong a word for it. "Coerced" is better.)

    One of the reasons Craig and I are such strong advocates of adoption for older children is because we, too, grieve such loss (and others like it) within our own extended family. Many, many times I've wondered if my loved ones would have made such terrible choices if they hadn't felt so alone — if I hadn't been thousands of miles away, and unavailable to help them every step of the way.

    In the Gospels, we read of a woman "caught" in adultery who is brought before Jesus to determine her fate. The Pharisees want to stone her; Jesus sets her free. Dear Jesus, make us more like you.

    Heidi Hess Saxton Editor, "Canticle" Magazine Blogroll

  6. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    How about this for a title: Words of Wisdom about Helping post-abortive Women.

    My sentiments will follow dierdrews. The parallel reality of a crime, murder and callousness needs to always be there as a contrast to the murky confusion of emotions. Compassion and admonition are inseparable in this case. The companion of these two approaches is not to go against each other but to clarify each other’s purpose. We seek God’s mercy in light of His justice.

    Yes, it is a painful subject. The pain inflicted on the unborn can not be appeased in any other way. It just got transferred to the mother, father, community and society. Not in all cases is the mother a coerced, confused victim. In too many cases she is a selfish, conniving and carefree individual. Condemnation of that kind of behavior is in order. Compassion is counterproductive when repentance has not taken place. This horrible act excommunicates a person until restorative action is taken. “There, there” is not going to fix it.

    It is for us to sense the wise and proper approach in each individual case. Every sin carries along with it the bitter medicine that is necessary for healing; sweetening it many times prolongs the pain. Don’t misunderstand, a grieving mother in this case needs help, but grieve she must.

    There is a tendency in our society to treat criminals as victims and give a pass to those who have done wrong to the detriment of the real victims who are also in pain. The pain of the little ones was silent and disposed so it doesn’t tug on our compassion strings. 

  7. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    To any mother or woman that has an abortion and then feels remorseful about it then we as Christians are obligated to console them.  To help them heal. They deserve our love.

    And being a guy there is no way I could ever understand the pain or feelings a woman that has an abortion experiences.  I do not agree with abortion but condemning women that have them or treating them as outcasts will not stop the this abortion holocaust.  My wife and I knew a couple that mistakenly convinced themselves to have an abortion when the wife/girlfriend became pregnant.  The couple was also friends of my wife's sister and husband.  When they learned that our mutual friends had an abortion they immediately shunned them.  Later (about a few weeks actually) the couple started to feel terrible about what they did they felt even worse when close friends (wife's sister and husband) refused to even talk to them.  That chore fell to my wife and I and we were separated by about 700 miles.  One of the hardest things I have had to do is to console someone over the phone.  My wife and I were honest with them and said that although we did not agree with their actions we would not condemn them in their time of need.  We encouraged them to seek help at their local parish. 

     

    Tarheel (Dave)

  8. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    This article is very good in bringing to the fore the complex nature of women having to live with a terrible decision they once (or more than once) made in their lives. In this article I read the words painful…humiliating…guilty…grieve…unhealthy behaviors…raw and painful…I think all would agree (and aborting women almost always answer in the affirmative) abortion can in no way be characterized as a “positive” life experience.

    A high percentage of aborting women live in the most highly populated states and large urban areas. One look at the color-coded map tells us that the aborting women live and vote in states with a disproportionate number of politicians who (in some cases) crow loudly in their defense of the Roe v. Wade decision and their voting record in defending “reproductive rights.” That, and Ms. Fredenburg’s article got me thinking and wondering.

    I’ll let Lt. Columbo ask the remainder of the questions: 

    From an imaginary Columbo mystery: Columbo investigates an abortionist suspected of murdering three of his patients in the past year. Lt. Columbo has just concluded an interview with Ms. Mercedes Miller, a woman who had an abortion by this same MD years before in another city where he had been tried and acquitted of a suspected homicide.  Columbo:  Suantering toward the door of Ms. Miller’s one-bedroom apartment, Columbo turn to her, places the tips of his fingers against his furrowed brow, and careful not to drop the unlit stub of his cigar, Columbo says,

     “Thank you once again for being so helpful today, Ms. Miller. But there’s just one thing I don’t quite understand. Maybe you can clear a dilemma up for me that’s begun to bother me ever since I took charge of this investigation. In my investigation of this case I’ve come across material about women who have gone through something the experts call ‘post-abortion syndrome.’ Now, I’m not a psychologist, but I was able to gather that a lot of women who have been through the abortion experience often go through a lot of inner pain, depression, guilt, anger, sometimes even end up dependent on drugs or alcohol or suicidal.

    “My question to you is this; maybe you can answer this, having been through the experience, because it makes no sense to me. There’s a disconnect somewhere. Here we are, living in one of these ‘blue states’ (Columbo waves his arms wide) where a lot of liberal politicians get voted back into office again and again. Hey, the gal in my district, liberal as the day is long, has been in Congress for over 20 years! Most of ‘em, especially the big name guys and gals, always seem to enjoy reminding the voters that they will continue to agressively protect something they call ‘reproductive right.’ I guess that’s just a clever code-word for abortion, huh? (Ms. Miller closes her eyes and silently nods).

    "If so many of these gals living in this state have experienced so much pain and trouble and heartache from these abortions, why do they keep voting back in the same crummy politicians that keep crowing that “reproductive rights” is a good thing for women, and seem to ignore all this mayhem that abortion causes? But then again, I’m just a gumshoe in a wrinkled trench coat doin’ my job, and politics has never been my specialty. What’s goin’ on here, Ms. Miller. This one’s got me baffled. (Columbo throws his arms up as if to say, ‘It’s beyond me!’)."

    Columbo smiles, nods, and leaves the apartment.

     To what are we to attribute this seemingly contradictory behavior: Yes, I regret my abortion, but no, I can’t bring myself to oppose those who continue to make it very easy for my younger sisters out there to do what I now deeply regret. Why does the post-abortive woman’s pain and grief not translate into anger and rejection in the voting booth of those who loudly defend the very act that has hurt her so deeply?

  9. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    Tarheel, as I understand your statements this abortion that took place was a deliberate and premeditated act. The decision was not kept private but was looking for approval. I would have to agree with your friends about shunning the couple. That's the practical experience of disapproval and excommunication. It's the enstrangement that primes the remorse that leads the way back, even if it's for the reason of someone's friendship.

    Your encouragement seems to have flowed here in proper order. The blood of the innocent also cries out and the Lord of Mercy is no less compelled to hear them.

  10. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    I have nothing to offer in this discussion.  I have nothing because I am nothing, except for my own thoughts and feelings.  I must pray for Jesus Christ to carry me so I can help women who have had abortions.  I having nothing to offer.  Not even my understanding.  Only Christ can provide anything I can offer.

    GK – God is good!

  11. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    Nice article. Can't think of one word to add to it!

  12. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    deirdrew– you sadly miss the point of the whole article.  Michaelene–very well done, thank you for your insights, may God richly bless you.

     

    You have made us for yourself, O Lord; and our hearts are restless until they rest in You. — St. Augustine

  13. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    I defend life from conception to natural death – no exceptions, no apologies.  But, we must have compassion for anyone who has gone through an abortion…even if she is still convincing herself that it was a "good choice".  Pray for those who do not see.  Anger and condemnation will NEVER prevail. 

    One day I was volunteering as a sidewalk counselor in Detroit. As I was silently praying for the mothers and babies inside the building, a woman brought her car to a screeching halt in front of me.  She got out and started screaming at me, calling me every single name in the book.  Her face was an inch from mine as she was spitting venom.  (I thought she would strike me at any minute.)  She kept yelling that this was a woman's 'choice'.  I calmly asked her what the choice was – to please finish the sentence.  She went on…"a woman's choice to do what she wants with her body!"  I asked her "what choice was that? please finish the sentence."  She kept screaming for what seemed to be an eternity but I let her go on without saying a word.  Soon after, a woman came out of the building and you could see in her eyes (the dead eyes) that she had just gone through with an abortion.  I asked her if she wanted a rosary.  I gave her a card with phone numbers she could call to seek help (compassionate help).  I gave her a hug and she hugged me back…the tears started to fall at that point, she thanked me for being there for her, then left – clutching the rosary and Project Rachael card.  The angry woman (who wasn't even there for an abortion – just there to yell at me) witnessed this exchange.  She then said that if I only offered to take these babies, these women wouldn't have to abort them.  I told her (again, calmly) that I have begged on my knees…they won't give me the babies.  I then told her that I had a picture of what the "choice" she kept referring to looked like.  I didn't force her to look at it, but she asked to see it.  It was a picture of a baby at 4 months gestation.  The woman said "That's not legal".  I assured her that it was.  I then went to 12 weeks…then 8 weeks.  The woman made reference to the fingers and toes.  She then asked me if I thought the woman who just had the abortion would get some help.  Then…she took my hand and said "God bless you, and from now on I promise I will finish the sentence!"

    The point is this.  If I would have screamed back at the angry woman from the start, nothing would have been accomplished.  She would not have heard one thing I had to say.  Even if I didn't scream but calmly condemned her, she would have gotten back in her car thinking she did her "good" deed for the day.  Secondly, if I did not have love and compassion for the woman who had the abortion, perhaps she would never know where to get help with a bad choice that she had made.  Perhaps she would never know that it is OKAY to grieve the loss of your child.  Perhaps she would never know that God will forgive if she seeks reconciliation and is absolutely sorry in her heart.  Who are we to judge anyone?  Even if someone makes a bad choice?  Haven't we all made a bad choice at one time or another?

  14. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    I think that many of the posts here are missing the point about what Michaelene's testimony is all about. Have any of you visited the website for the outreach that she leads? It's http://www.abortionchangesyou.com. So many of these comment posts keep referring back to the woman or the child as if these are the only ones affected by the abortion. How sad is it that we forget the men, grandparents, surviving siblings and friends who have been equally affected by their abortion experience! This outreach that Michaelene has launched is absolutely profound and as Catholics, we should recognize that it perfectly responds to the Gospel message which excludes no one from Christ's love and mercy. I challenge everyone on this thread to visit this site and explore the stories of these men and women whose lives have been affected by an abortion decision. After 35 years, it's the absolute right time for this outreach. It is desperately needed for so many hurting people. Each one of you know someone who has felt alone or isolated because of their abortion experience, but maybe its your own rhetoric that has kept them from sharing it with you. This website gives them a place to go. Kudos Michaelene! I applaud your courage, your compassion and your concern for the forgotten.  I will share your site with everyone I know.Innocent

  15. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    I think it is problematic to discuss this issue in a blog forum.  Nuances aren't conveyed.  Misunderstandings may occur.

    I believe abortion is murder.  Period.  That is why I have a disgust for all the parties who willfully participated in the process: pregnant women, the father, grandmothers, abortion staff, politicians, etc…I think a lot of us are concerned that post abortive women et al have become THE victims…How many categories of people who commit homicide are viewed as victims? Why do women who abort get excused because they were in college or "shacking up" and then were "scared" of something.  Many murderers have compelling sob stories too.

    However, Christ held out forgiveness for murders who repent.  So although like GK I can never understand the abortion decision, and by the grace of God never was in that position, I do forgive them and want all parties to live in the peace of Christ.

    God alone will judge.  He will determine purgatory and we can make reparation for those sinners along with ourselves.

    ….I'm intrigued with the Columbo dialogue (Where is he?  I loved him!)

    Michaelene may have a response to Columbo.  Certainly, she doesn't fall in that category of silent or complicit post abortive women.  Check out the silentnomore campaign. 

  16. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    Michaeline,

    Thank you for sharing this experience and the story of your re-conversion back to the Church.  Your story is the answer to the age old question, Why does God allow bad things to happen?  Answer, for the greater good. Your child may have lost its life so that others, through your help, may save theirs.

  17. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    I am the father of an aborted child.  I was married to the mother and wanted the child.  She simply did not want to have babies.  I foolishly thought I could change her mind after we were married.  I found out how wrong I was when she aborted our baby.  So, not only did I devastate my own life by my wrong-headedness, but I devstated the life of my child, too.  I named the baby Shawn.  It took a long time for me to accept God's awesome forgiveness.  I am trying to start a ministry in my diocese for post-abortive fathers who want to heal but don't know where to go.  Please pray that we get this ministry implemented soon!

    And, please pray for all the fathers of aborted babies.

     

    The rest of the story is that God eventually blessed me with a Godly wife and four beautiful children.  Our first grandchild is going to be born in about ten weeks!  What an awesome God we serve!

  18. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    Jayreilly,

    thank you for sharing your story.  I'm sorry for your loss.  I pray your ministry flourishes.  There are lots of men who are suffering.  We are all in need of Christ's healing…He want us to drink from the Living Water.

    Congratulations on your grandbaby! 

  19. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    Thank you Elkabrikir, for your kind words!

    One of the most wonderful things about God is how He takes the tragedies of our lives and allows us to use them to help others through the tragedies of their lives, if we just let Him work in our lives.  Through our pain and suffering joined to Jesus' pain and suffering on the cross, we can "make up in our own bodies for that which is lacking in the suffering of Christ", as St.Paul so beautifully put it!

    Because of sin in the world, God must allow suffering and pain, but He then has given us a means of making our pain and suffering meaningful, even the pain and suffering of losing a child through abortion.

    Even after 33 years, I still grieve the loss of my child.  However, a beautiful thing happened on January 22, 2008 while at Mass; I was led by the Holy Spirit to ask Shawn to forgive me and Shawn's mother for the abortion.  What a burden I felt lifted off my shoulders then!

    As Rev. Dr. James Keating says, "There's no easy way to salvation — there's only the Way of the Cross!"

  20. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    Thoughtful and inspiring article, Michaelene, thank you.  Many of us miss the point–in abortions that have already occurred, the only victim able to receive our help is the mother.  And make no mistake, women seeking post-abortion healing have already carried more grief, shame, remorse, and "disgust" than any of us are capable of inflicting upon them(and their "sob stories.")  Despite all the pro-abort rhetoric, I doubt it ever feels like a choice.  And when it is coerced(the minors dragged to the clinic by parents or worse, their rapists) the shame and guilt aren't any lighter.  What about the women deceived?  Those who believed the "blob of tissue" lie before the advent of ultrasonography?  Why does everyone feel called to judge these women, or push them aside for their dead children?  Father Pavone is forever reminding us to love them both–they need to be healed by Christ and forgiven so they can fulfill their mission and be the women God created in love.  And the virtue of Charity compels us to desire the best for these women, namely their healing and reconciliation with Christ and his church.  The consequences if they aren't healed are many–they can abuse substances, themselves, and their subsequent children(and other pregnant women in some cases).  Those children can wind up at the same clinics…I have met at least one.  If you want to save children, heal the mothers and LISTEN to them, their voices and stories raised in the service of life are powerful and difficult for the pro-aborts to silence.

    Remember, a rosary is a powerful weapon in this spiritual war.

  21. Guest Avatar
    Guest

    csandkc:

    I agree with your entire post.

    What I have tried to point out is that those of us who have not experienced abortion directly may have a difficult time getting to your point.  I think understanding from your "side" towards those who "judge" needs to occur too.  Many can't believe anybody could ever be coerced into killing the fruit of their womb.  

     

    I think it takes heroic charity, achievable united to Christ, to forgive a category of people who have participated in killing tens of millions.  Therefore, forgiveness probably occurs at the individual level:  the the person before you.  So, Michaelene is correct in that you never know the history of the person before and should keep that in mind when you speak of abortion.

    Jay… I have lost several nieces/nephews to abortion.  They would have been the same age as my children.  I wonder about them and who they would have been.  I see the hole in my family and grieve.  I don't think that sadness will ever go away.  I'm thankful you are continuing to heal. 

Leave a Reply