Catholic Exchange

Winning the Heart of a Child

I watched my three-year-old’s face light up in the glow of his new toy, a faux-computer for toddlers designed to teach letter and number recognition. Immediately captivated, he danced back and forth hopping from foot to foot, impatient as I tore away the packaging.

“Give it to me, Mommy! I love it!”

He hadn’t even seen what it could do yet. But he knew that he loved it.

I smiled and handed it over, satisfied but also troubled, on some level. It wasn’t until I was lying in bed later that night that I could really put my finger on why.

He was more excited by that toy then by anything we’d done together that day. It’s influence over him was more apparent and maybe greater than mine, in that moment.

I realize that to be mother or father is to become slowly and surely irrelevant, in the most positive sense. As our children grow up, they, by design, grow away from us, maturing in independence and competence and, please God, virtue.

But this felt different. It felt, to my melancholic musings, like a snapshot preview into a possible future. A future that will be filled with competing voices vying for our children’s attention, voices that will be at times louder and more persuasive than mine or my husband’s. Voices whose influence I might resent, or even oppose.

We’ve got such a limited window, I thought to myself, lying in the dark of my bedroom, fighting a rising feeling of anxiety. How can we make the most of the time we have left to be the main influence in their lives?

I don’t propose to have definitive answers. With the way technology is evolving and with the introduction of devices targeting younger and younger consumers, the inevitable march of progress demands that competing voices will raise themselves and demand the attention of our kids. I know this. And I’m not anti-technology! There is so much good to be done via the internet, as our Holy Father would have us believe. As would his predecessor. And the one before him, too.

It’s what we do with technology that informs its nature. And it’s what we do with our children in terms of preparation and cultivation and training that helps to shape theirs.

Are some temperaments going to be easier to coax along in terms of virtue and obedience and critical thinking? I’m thinking yes. And for our eldest son, a consummate sanguine if ever one was born, I’m recognizing the lure of shiny screens and exciting and beautiful images is almost irresistible.

So it’s my job, then, to meet the child God designed – fearfully and wonderfully, I might add – and do my very best to raise him up to the level of holiness God has called him to. Sainthood, to be precise.

No big deal, right?

The thought alone is enough to make even a seasoned mother blanch. I’m only 4 years into this gig, and I’m shaking in my disciplinary boots. When I see his eyes light up like that over a simple toy, or when I see the fierce desire he harbors for my iPhone and my laptop, I cannot help but face the future with a bit of trepidation.

I think that’s probably a good thing.

I have, best I can figure it, approximately 8 more years before my primary influence over him begins to wane and peer and media influences begin to take my place. Even if we homeschool. Even without cable. Heck, even if we decided to forgo home internet connectivity.

It is unavoidable that my children will become influenced by forces beyond my control.

And that’s okay.

My job, I’m realizing with a painful lump in my throat and a pang of sadness in my heart, is to raise them up and away from me. To equip them with the necessary training in virtue and discernment and critical thinking skills to help them meet and evaluate those influences and then…make their own decisions.

It hurts.

It hurts thinking that with every meal, every nighttime nursing session and every new skill transmitted, I’m equipping my babies to leave me. But it’s in my job description. It is my job description. To mother is to release, to send out.

The real question I’m grappling with these days is how to make the most of the minutes (the sometimes long, long tedious minutes) and hours and days and the few, precious years I’ve been given dominion over their little spirits. What can I say – or not say – in this moment, in this difficult situation, in this epic sibling throw-down, that will resonate into eternity?

Usually I don’t hit quite the right note.

Most days I’m vacillating between losing my temper and admitting defeat under a relentless barrage of requests for cartoons and yogurt tubes. I’m either a stern authoritarian with a mean streak or a flabby failure flopped on the couch, a laptop spinning the latest from PBS Kids, holding their rapt attention from the coffee table.

It’s a struggle. But it’s one I must engage. I must, because if I don’t rise to the occasion of training the wildness and the willfulness out of them, the culture will train them. And as I look around and see little people who have been formed and influenced by the culture we inhabit, I cringe to think what the future might hold for my own small people if mommy doesn’t get her act together.

It’s ironic that some of the struggles I foresee being most intense for them – namely, the capacity to engage technology in a meaningful way that isn’t dehumanizing or damaging, is also one of my greatest struggles as a stay at home mom. And ultimately, what influences mommy will influence the entire family, for better or for worse. I can’t check out during these intense, exhausting early years and expect to wake up to reasonable seven-year-olds who have excellent attention spans and a taste for classic literature. It’s all me right now. And that is both terrifying and awe-inspiring.

Does good parenting guarantee a good result? By no means. And can kids from great families turn out really rotten? Absolutely. But no matter the variables, I still have to step up to the plate and pitch my innings. And every afternoon that I manage to resist the pull to veg out with a magazine or vent out on social media instead of leaving it all on the field during the 3-5 pm graveyard shift when my house becomes overrun with wild animals crazed for carbohydrates, I win the day.

God, give me the strength to power through till dinner time, and the wisdom to know when it’s perfectly acceptable to hand over the last 30 minutes before daddy gets home to Curious George.

Comments

12 responses to “Winning the Heart of a Child”

  1. JenG Avatar
    JenG

    I feel like you live in my house. Curious George and yoghurt tubes are simultaneously my best friends and arch enemies. Great article – puts in to words so many of my feelings on mothering.

  2. Claire Avatar
    Claire

    I totally relate to this article. I cry about the fact that as a mother, I’m working my way out of a job. I fear the outside influences that I can’t control, and I’m overwhelmed by the responsibility entrusted to me and how often I jeopardize that by my mistakes as a mother and a witness.

  3. noelfitz Avatar
    noelfitz

    This is another great article in CE.

    I read here “There is so much good to be done via the internet”. I agree and part of it is reading CE.

  4. gsk Avatar
    gsk

    What you say is true on a material level, Jenny. We are forming little people to take their place in the world — competently, creatively, and confidently. And yet the “sending out” is not really leaving if they cleave to their baptism. In that sense, you are forming souls to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with you before the throne of God — fully human, fully alive, and bound to you in a way that is far greater (and more intimate!) than flesh and blood.

  5. Elizabeth Avatar
    Elizabeth

    I’m sorry to be posting a second time. But this article and the comments have really resonated with me. (The last line of my last post was supposed to by: “It WON’T all depend on you anymore). This topic is something I’ve struggled with and thought about a lot over the years. Jenny, I want to tell you that I really enjoy your columns. You are always so real, so honest, and pretty funny! It sounds like you are doing a great job with your kids. I especially wanted to answer Claire, from the comments. I used to feel very much like you do, very fearful of the future for my little kids and overwhelmed with my role in their lives. I used to be really involved in pro-life and was so painfully conscious of all the bad stuff out there. But one time I heard a talk by Michael O’Brien (Catholic artist and author) that gave me a lot of peace. He said that if we create a culture of life in our homes, and our children have tasted that good life, they won’t be drawn to the culture of death. Of course, there is always free will. Kids can still make bad choices, but it makes it a lot less likely that they will. And we will know, in good conscience, that we did all we could do and have to leave the rest to God. I still think that we have to find a balance and still battle the forces that fight for our kids (by being involved in pro-life etc), but this really helped me to feel more empowered to win our kids’ hearts in positive ways. Secondly, Claire, I’ve realized as I look back over our 18 years of parenting, that I could have relaxed a little more in the early years. All that culture-creating was great, but sometimes a culture of life can be just being together, doing a bunch of nothing. And to comment on Jenny, and your craving time-out for yourself and just needing to flop without little people needing things from you: I know that struggle so well, especially in the afternoon. The thing that helped me the most with that was a book called “A Mother’s Rule of Life” by Holly Pierlot. She encourages mothers to find the natural rhythm in their day and then try to schedule around that. That way, it is so much easier to plow through the working parts of the day, knowing that you have scheduled in the much-needed flop and veg-out times. And then you can enjoy those times as a mother guilt-free because you planned it. I HIGHLY recommend that book to any mom. And one more thing to Claire: so many times as a younger mother I felt like I really blew it with my kids, and would lie in bed at night feeling so guilty about whatever had transpired that day. I finally started praying, “God, please protect my children emotional and spiritually from what happened today (losing my temper, etc).” I’m not condoning the bad days, and I do need to keep trying to do better, but it occurred to me that when I fail, damage to the children is not inevitable. Maybe God can protect them from it and even use if for good somehow. Keep up the good fight. God bless your efforts.

  6. Claire Avatar
    Claire

    Marie, thank you so much for your reply, as well as your comments below. For some reason I’m just now seeing this comment for the first time (your most recent comment came to my inbox, but the others didn’t for some reason). I really appreciate your perspective on this. It’s very helpful to hear from an experienced mom who is farther down the road of motherhood than I am.

  7. Claire Avatar
    Claire

    Oh sorry, I just re-read your comment and see that you are not yet a mom, but clearly being part of a large family has given you a lot of insight into this issue.

  8. Claire Avatar
    Claire

    Thank you so much for your encouragement Elizabeth. It really helps to put things in perspective. Thanks for sharing your experience and the insights you have developed along the path.

  9. Marie Avatar
    Marie

    Elizabeth, I love this! What a great description of the beauties of a healthy Catholic family.

  10. Kristi Avatar
    Kristi

    This is a beautiful and helpful comment to young mothers “in the trenches”! Thank you.

  11. Kristi Avatar
    Kristi

    I have felt many of these exact emotions as a mother of little ones, especially on the long days alone. This sentence really struck me: “Most days I’m vacillating between losing my temper and admitting defeat …”
    Thank you for letting us know we’re not alone in our struggles, and for reminding us the value of staying engaged and present, whenever it’s humanly possible!

  12. Angela Avatar
    Angela

    I just wanted to say that though your words hold truth, there is some room for the other side. As a kid of such parents (although I haven’t been labeled as a kid for several years now) I felt I should side with the opposite of what you said. It is certainly true that as a ten year old I got very excited when holidays rolled around for the “things” I would get, but in recent years I have come to understand that something that made me just as excited was when my mom or dad would spend time alone with me (unless I was in trouble and about to get a lecture.) Coming from a big family this makes sense, but I believe that single children also enjoy undivided attention from their parents. We will go through a time when that attention may bother us (teens), I wouldn’t know as I have yet to experience it. My greatest wish today is to spend some time alone with my mom, which is only made worse by the fact that she passed away several years ago. Perhaps this is what fuels my wish, but I know that before she left for a better place I was spending hours calling her just to talk. I could go on for hours on this subject, like how personality will play a role, and how everyone responds differently to different stimuli, but I need to be brief. Basically, don’t discount that you are having an affect.

Leave a Reply